Quill Calls vs CallRail: an honest comparison
Quill Calls is a call tracking and attribution tool for businesses that want to know which marketing makes the phone ring. It is a CallRail alternative that includes recording, transcription, AI call summaries and lead scoring in every plan, starting at $59 a month. CallRail is the best-known product in this category and does several things Quill Calls does not. This page lays out both.
Competitor information on this page was read from each company's own public website on November 10, 2026. Prices and features change; check their sites before deciding.
The short version
Both products do the core job: you get tracking phone numbers, a script swaps the number each website visitor sees, calls forward to your real line, and each call is reported against the campaign that produced it. The difference is mostly in how each one is packaged and how much surrounding product there is.
Quill Calls is the smaller, simpler product. There are three plans, and every plan has every feature. You pay more only when you need more tracking numbers, minutes or users. CallRail sells a wider range: its pricing page lists four plans, with transcription and call analysis in the higher two, plus form tracking and an AI voice assistant that answers calls.
Side by side
| Quill Calls | CallRail | |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $59/month (Starter) | $50/month plus additional usage (Lead Tracking) |
| Plans | Starter $59, Growth $129, Scale $249 a month | Lead Tracking $50, Lead Tracking Complete $95, Lead Conversion $150, Lead Conversion Complete $195 a month, each plus additional usage |
| Free trial | No free trial; billed monthly | 14-day free trial on every account |
| Tracking numbers and dynamic number insertion | Yes, every plan | Yes |
| Call recording | Yes, every plan | Yes |
| Transcription, AI summary and lead scoring | Included in every plan | Transcription and analysis minutes are listed with the Lead Conversion plans |
| Form tracking | Form submissions are captured by the same site snippet | Included from Lead Tracking Complete |
| AI voice assistant that answers calls | No | Yes (Voice Assist, priced separately) |
| Healthcare | Technical safeguards described on our security page; ask us about vendor agreements before sending patient information | States that it signs a business associate agreement with healthcare clients |
CallRail figures are monthly list prices from callrail.com/pricing. CallRail's page also offers a discount for yearly billing. Check their site for current pricing before you decide.
Where Quill Calls is the better fit
- You want AI call summaries, transcripts and a lead score on every call without choosing a higher tier. In Quill Calls these are in the Starter plan.
- You want a bill you can predict. Each plan is a flat monthly price with a set number of tracking numbers and minutes.
- You care about the full path to the call. Quill Calls stores the source that first introduced the caller and the source that brought them back, separately, so an ad that started the relationship still gets credit.
- You want a quick install. One script tag finds your phone number on the page in any format and swaps it, including on site builders where you cannot edit the markup.
- You also use, or are considering, Quill Hound Voice for your phone system or Spar Hound for sales coaching. They are built by the same company and work together.
Where CallRail is the better choice
CallRail has been doing this for much longer, and it shows in breadth. Choose CallRail if any of these matter to you:
- You want to try before paying. CallRail gives every account a 14-day free trial. Quill Calls does not have a free trial.
- You want an AI assistant that answers the phone. CallRail sells Voice Assist; Quill Calls only tracks and analyzes calls that your own team answers.
- You are a healthcare organization that needs a signed business associate agreement from the vendor today. CallRail says on its pricing page that it signs one with each healthcare client. With Quill Calls, that is a conversation to have with us before you send patient information.
- You want the best-known, longest-established product in the category.
What Quill Calls costs
Starter is $59 a month with 3 tracking numbers, 300 minutes and 1 user; Growth is $129 a month with 10 tracking numbers, 1,000 minutes and 5 users; Scale is $249 a month with 25 tracking numbers, 3,000 minutes and unlimited users. If you need more numbers or minutes than Scale includes, contact us for a custom plan.
| Plan | Price | Tracking numbers | Minutes a month | Users |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starter | $59/month | 3 | 300 | 1 |
| Growth | $129/month | 10 | 1,000 | 5 |
| Scale | $249/month | 25 | 3,000 | Unlimited |
Other call tracking tools worth a look
If you are comparing the whole category, two other products publish their pricing. WhatConverts lists single-account plans from $30 a month (Call Tracking) up to $160 a month (Elite), each with a 14-day free trial, and tracks forms and chats as well as calls from its Plus plan up. CallTrackingMetrics (CTM) lists plans from $79 a month (Marketing Lite) plus usage, and also covers call routing and contact-center features. Both are broader lead-tracking platforms than Quill Calls.
Switching from CallRail
Moving is mostly a matter of numbers and one script tag. Pick a Quill Calls plan, create tracking numbers for your campaigns, point each one at the line you already answer, and replace the old script on your site with the Quill Calls snippet. Run both side by side for a week or two if you want to compare reports before turning the old one off. Tracking numbers printed on existing ads or listings stay with the provider that owns them, so plan to update those.
Quick answers
Is Quill Calls cheaper than CallRail?
It depends on what you need. Quill Calls starts at $59 a month with recording, transcription, AI summaries and lead scoring included. CallRail's lowest plan is listed at $50 a month plus usage, and its transcription and analysis features are listed with its Lead Conversion plans from $150 a month (prices read on November 10, 2026).
Does Quill Calls have everything CallRail has?
No. Quill Calls covers tracking numbers, dynamic number insertion, recording, transcription, AI summaries, lead scoring and first-touch plus last-touch attribution. CallRail also offers a free trial, dedicated form-tracking plans and an AI voice assistant that answers calls, which Quill Calls does not.
Can I use Quill Calls for a medical or dental practice?
Quill Calls is built with safeguards such as audit-logged recording access, signed links, role-scoped access and configurable retention. That is not a compliance certification. If calls will include patient information, contact Quill Calls first to confirm which vendor agreements are in place for your account.
Sources
- CallRail pricing (read November 10, 2026)
- WhatConverts pricing (read November 10, 2026)
- CTM plans and pricing (read November 10, 2026)